Carhartt Gilliam Jacket Best Overall
- Fit
- Relaxed
- Sizing
- Standard and tall
- Listed Weight
- 1.2 lb
- Weather Protection
- Water- and wind-resistant
Set the Gilliam next to the ski-style jackets here and the difference is obvious: this one is built for the cold you live in, not the storm you drive to twice a winter. It's our overall pick because it handles the most jobs — over a flannel on a frosty morning, under a rain shell when the wind picks up, around the barn in November — without the bulk of a parka. Carhartt lists it at 1.2 pounds, and on the body it feels closer to a heavy sweatshirt than a coat.
What sells it for outdoor work is the shell. It turns wind and light rain, the relaxed cut leaves room for a hoodie without binding across the shoulders, and the tall sizes are cut for a long frame — the sleeves land where they should, which is more than we can say for most jackets at this weight. The pockets are numerous and zippered, deep enough for a pair of gloves.
Two things to know. The side pockets sit at an angle, handy with gloves on and less so for anything small you drop into them. And this is a three-season layer: below the low 40s with only a shirt underneath, you'll want a fleece under it. Neither is a reason to pass, since layering is the whole point of a jacket this light.
What We Like
- Light enough to layer all winter
- Blocks wind and sheds light rain
- Relaxed cut fits over a hoodie
- Tall sizes with proper sleeve length
Worth Noting
- Angled side pockets can spill small items
- Wants a fleece layer below the low 40s
We recommend the Gilliam as the synthetic insulated jacket most people will reach for most often: light enough to layer, weatherproof enough for chores, and cut roomy enough to wear over real winter clothes.
Check Latest Price