Columbia Arcadia II Best Overall
- Hood
- Adjustable
- Sizing
- Extended fit available
- Packable
- Yes
- Waterproofing
- Fully waterproof
The Arcadia II is the jacket we reach for when we want one shell to cover a commute, a walk, and a trip. It is fully waterproof, packs down, and has an adjustable hood, which sounds basic until you wear a shell that gets one of those wrong. The cut leaves room for a light sweater without feeling billowy, and the fabric is quiet enough for everyday wear. This is the safest default here for most women.
We paid close attention to the hood and cuffs because that is where a packable jacket usually gives itself away. The hood adjusts and stays put in wind, the cuffs seal without cutting off circulation, and the jacket has kept its shape after being folded into a tote. We sized up to leave room for a midlayer, and the extra room felt useful rather than sloppy. Extended sizes help, but they do not make the fit universal.
The Arcadia II does not try to be a winter coat or a fashion trench, and that is the point. It is the shell we trust when the forecast is wrong and we do not want to carry a second layer. If you need warmth built in, look at the fleece-lined pick below; if you want one jacket that handles a wet week away, this is it.
What We Like
- Fully waterproof for real rain
- Packs small for travel
- Adjustable hood stays put
Worth Noting
- Chest runs narrow for some builds
For the widest range of wet-weather days, we recommend the Arcadia II: it is fully waterproof, packable, and easy to layer without bulk.
Check Latest Price