Irish Setter Wingshooter Best Overall
- Insulation
- Uninsulated
- Waterproofing
- Waterproof
- Width Options
- Wide sizes available
Rubber comes in one width. That single fact decides most of this category, and it is why the Wingshooter is our top pick: this is the boot here you can order in an actual wide size instead of going up a length and hoping the volume follows. Laces do the rest — you can open the forefoot over the widest part of your foot and still keep the heel locked down, which is the adjustment no pull-on can make.
Waterproof leather with no insulation makes it the most useful three-season boot on this list. On a warm October walk-in it does not cook your feet the way an 800-gram rubber boot does, and on a wet, cold morning the leather keeps the water out; we stood in wet grass and shallow puddles without a leak. Ankle support is there without the break-in heavy leather usually demands. What it is not is a late-season boot — sitting still below freezing, you need insulation and a heavy sock.
The outsole is the part that gives out first. The leather upper outlasts it, so plan on a resole rather than a replacement, and expect faster wear if a lot of your walking happens on gravel and pavement. What keeps us recommending it is the fit: for once, a wide forefoot does not have to be the compromise you shop around.
What We Like
- Sold in genuine wide sizes
- Laces adjust over a wide forefoot
- Waterproof leather without an insulating liner
- Supportive without a long break-in
Worth Noting
- Outsole wears out before the leather does
For wide feet this is the one we point people to: an actual wide size, laces that adjust over a wide forefoot, and waterproof leather that works from opening day to the rut.
Check Latest Price