Irish Setter Mesabi 8" Best Overall
- Toe
- Steel toe
- Height
- 8 inches
- Insulation
- Uninsulated
- Waterproofing
- Waterproof
The Mesabi is the classic logger shape done with enough restraint for all-season work: an 8-inch leather upper, a steel toe, and a waterproof boot that is not insulated. That last part matters more than the label suggests. An uninsulated waterproof logger handles wet spring mornings and still makes sense when the afternoon warms up, which is why it earns the default recommendation for most people.
We like the steel toe for job-site protection, but the fit is the part to slow down for. The Mesabi runs narrow and small, especially through the instep, and the wide width is not a cure-all. If you are between sizes, go up; if you have a high instep or a very wide forefoot, try the wide and expect to lace carefully. The payoff is a boot that feels locked in once broken in, with a logger heel that bites into soft ground and a shaft that supports the ankle without feeling like a cast.
Durability is where the Mesabi earns its keep. The leather and stitching hold up to heavy construction and wet limerock, and the waterproofing keeps feet dry in rain and shallow puddles. Break-in is the trade-off. The first few shifts can be stiff and uncomfortable, especially around the instep and heel. We do not treat the first hour as a verdict; wear them around the house and on short jobs before a full shift.
What We Like
- Waterproof, uninsulated build works across three seasons
- 8-inch steel toe gives job-site protection
- Leather and stitching hold up to heavy work
Worth Noting
- Heel can feel tippy on flat concrete
The Mesabi is the logger boot we recommend to most people: an 8-inch steel toe, waterproof leather, and a year-round build that holds up without roasting your feet.
Check Latest Price